Wives and career coaches have at least one challenge in common: A study by PsychTests.com using their Coachability Test reveals that men are less willing to take direction and criticism.
*Montreal, Canada – Executive coaching is a serious business. U.S. companies are spending more than one billion every year on coaching services. So one would hope that all employees would be open to the idea of receiving this type of guidance, but research from PsychTests reveals that male employees may prove to be a challenge.
Athletes understand the importance of listening to a coach. Even the “prima donnas” of the sports world know that not heeding a coach’s instruction could translate into trouble, or at least less playing time. Putting ego aside and swallowing pride is necessary when receiving feedback or coaching, whether in the sports or business world. The problem is that a lot of people are unwilling to accept guidance from others – and according to data from PsychTests, men in particular.
Here’s how men and women compared:
· Women are more coachable overall than men (score of 75 vs. 71 on a scale from 0 to 100)
· Women are better at handling criticism (74 vs. 69)
· Women are more open to learning and improvement (85 vs. 81)
· Women are more willing to take direction (70 vs. 67)
Other differences between men and women:
· 2% of women vs. 7% of men believe that they don’t have any weaknesses.
· 3% of women vs. 10% of men think that performance evaluations are a waste of time, because they are already good at what they do.
· 5% of women vs.11% of men will immediately shut down and stop listening as soon as they hear a negative comment about their work. (This is why nagging is a waste of time).
· 7% of women vs. 16% of men admit that they exaggerate or over-estimate their professional skills.
· 9% of women vs. 22% of men believe that they are much more knowledgeable than most people.
· 10% of women vs. 25% of men believe that there is no point in pursuing a goal if you need other people’s help to achieve it.
· 19% of women vs. 27% of men don’t like admitting to others when they are having difficulty understand something, or are unfamiliar with the topic of conversation.
· 85% of women vs. 79% of men are open to advice and suggestions from their manager.
· If asked to list their faults, 10% of women and15% of men would have a hard time coming up with any.
During a performance review:
· 5% of women vs.12% of men threatened to quit after a performance review.
· 5% of women vs. 10% of men actually quit after a performance review.
· 13% of women vs. 30% of men told the critic that he/she is “wrong” or “misinformed”.
· 25% of women vs. 34% of men agreed to improve/implement changes but never followed through.
· 27% of women vs. 41% of men openly disagreed with the feedback they received.
“To be able to accept help, feedback, criticism, and direction requires a degree of comfort with vulnerability – and this is what puts off a lot of people,” explains Dr. Jerabek, president of the company. “You have to be able to look at your performance and recognize that, even if you are an experienced professional, there are always areas where you can do better – where you can learn and grow. Coaching is just a means to bring out your full potential, and is in no way a sign that you are incompetent. Companies won’t spend billions of dollars on coaching for people that they don’t believe in.”
Researchers at PsychTests broached the subject of coachability with men of various ages and professions in order to better understand why men are less receptive. These were some of the responses … uncensored:
“Because men feel like they can do anything on their own without the help of a coach or anyone else. Just like if a wife asks her husband to call a plumber to fix the toilet – he’s most likely going to try fixing it himself before calling for help, just like getting directions and just like being coached. They feel powerless when they’re being coached; like they’re being molded into an image, or are inferior to the coach…which is why they tend to act out and say, ‘I know how to do it’ or ‘I know what I’m doing’. They don’t want to feel useless or inferior which makes them hard to coach because men are know-it-alls. We want to feel like we’re in control. We’re afraid of having our manhood taken away.” Dario, 24 years old
“Perhaps because traditionally men view a need for help (or improvement) as weakness. Same reason they don’t like to ask for directions.” Tom, 52 years old
Want to assess your level of coachability? Go to http://testyourself.psychtests.com/testid/3478
Professional users of this assessment (HR professionals, therapists, coaches and consultants) can request a free demo of this or any other tests from ARCH Profile’s extensive battery: http://hrtests.archprofile.com/testdrive_gen_1
About PsychTests AIM Inc.:
PsychTests AIM Inc. originally appeared on the internet scene in 1996. Since its inception, it has become a pre-eminent provider of psychological assessment products and services to human resource personnel, therapists, academics, researchers and a host of other professionals around the world. PsychTests AIM Inc. staff is comprised of a dedicated team of psychologists, test developers, researchers, statisticians, writers, and artificial intelligence experts (see ARCHProfile.com). The company’s research division, Plumeus Inc., is supported in part by Research and Development Tax Credit awarded by Industry Canada.
Ilona Jerabek, Ph.D.
President of PsychTests AIM Inc.
9001 Boul. De L’Acadie, Suite 802
Montreal, Quebec, H4N 3H5
tel: 514-745-3189, ext. 112